Summary: The history of paint reveals how innovation transformed artistic possibility. Once rare and costly, vivid pigments became widely available through chemistry, commerce, and competition. New colors and portable paint tubes helped artists experiment and made movements such as Impressionism possible. Today, safer and more affordable paints give ordinary people creative opportunities once reserved for a privileged few.


In the 2017 film Tulip Fever, set in Amsterdam in the 1630s, a young Dutch Golden Age artist is commissioned to paint a merchant’s wife wearing a dark blue dress. The artist shows the merchant’s wife the paint on his easel and tells her it is “ultramarine blue; the old Italian masters used it for the mother of Jesus. Do you know why they used it? Because it’s the color that costs the most. Ultramarine blue from over the sea, made from a blue stone found in one place only.”

In the 17th century, ultramarine blue was rare, expensive, and extremely labor-intensive to produce. To make the pigment, painters ground lapis lazuli, a blue semi-precious stone mined in what is now Afghanistan, into powder, kneaded it into a dough of wax, resin, and oil, and then worked the dough by hand in warm lye for days until the blue particles separated from the rest of the stone. According to research published by London’s National Gallery, in 1626 an ounce of ultramarine bought in Antwerp for Peter Paul Rubens’s Assumption of the Virgin cost 45 guilders, or approximately 62 days’ wages for an unskilled laborer in the city.1

Today, ultramarine blue is just another color. Anyone can buy an ounce of synthetic pigment for about $2.50, roughly four minutes of the average American worker’s pay, or about 20 minutes at the federal minimum wage. In other words, assuming an eight-hour workday, a minimum-wage American worker could buy about 1,400 ounces of the pigment today in the time it took an unskilled Antwerpian to buy one ounce 400 years ago. Nor is the abundance of ultramarine blue unique. Dozens of other colors that were rare and expensive a couple of centuries ago are now commonplace on even the poorest artist’s palette, including vermilion red, azurite blue, and cochineal crimson.

The history of colors is a quiet but captivating record of human progress. Until the late 18th century, Western artists’ palettes were shaped by geography, trade, and the support of wealthy patrons, rather than pure imagination and experimentation. For most of human history, people have laboriously extracted colors from minerals, plants, and insects, meaning the available palette was limited.

Venetian painters had a more diverse palette than most other artists. Thanks to Venice’s role and important location in 16th-century trade, artists there could access rare pigments imported from the East, such as ultramarine blue and yellow orpiment, sooner and more easily than the painters elsewhere in Europe. Titian’s Bacchus and Ariadne (1520–23), with its sky of vivid ultramarine, shows what that access made possible. Outside such trade hubs, though, most painters across Europe before the 19th century worked with a handful of cheaper pigments: lead white, ivory black, yellow and red ochre, and umber.

Things changed dramatically in the late 18th century. During the Industrial Revolution, chemists across Europe raced to understand elements and chemical reactions to invent new colors for porcelain and textile manufacturing, as well as interior design for the growing middle class. Driven by that demand, new colors and techniques emerged, expanding artists’ palettes and ultimately changing art history, first in Europe and then worldwide.

The progress in color from the late 18th century to the mid-19th century was riveting. Competing chemists discovered new colors and found cheaper ways to make rare ones. In 1775, Swedish chemist Carl Wilhelm Scheele invented a vivid green pigment, now known as Scheele’s green, and in 1814 manufacturers in Schweinfurt, Germany, developed a brighter variant called emerald green. In 1817, German chemist Friedrich Stromeyer discovered the element cadmium, which soon gave painters cadmium red and cadmium yellow. 

Ultramarine followed. In 1824, France’s Society for the Encouragement of National Industry offered a prize of 6,000 francs (approximately $250,000 in today’s money) to anyone who could cheaply produce synthetic ultramarine. Two chemists, Jean-Baptiste Guimet in France and Christian Gmelin in Germany, raced independently to claim the prize. In 1828, Guimet won the prize and his synthetic ultramarine sold for roughly a tenth of the price of the natural pigment (although Gmelin insisted for years that he had discovered the synthesizing method first).

As with many innovations, some breakthroughs were lucky happenstances. In 1856, William Perkin, an 18-year-old Englishman, accidentally discovered mauve, a purple dye that permanently colored silk, while trying and failing to synthesize quinine, a treatment for malaria. The textile industry quickly adopted the color. 

None of these breakthroughs followed a central plan. Even the ultramarine prize only set a goal with a reward, leaving chemists to find their own routes to it. The colors that transformed the history of art and industry came from competition, commerce, and the occasionally lucky accident. 

With the invention of these new colors, European artists became obsessed with color, giving rise to one of the most exciting art movements: Impressionism. A humbler invention helped too. In 1841, American painter John Goffe Rand patented the collapsible tin paint tube, which kept paint fresh and made painting outdoors far easier. Renoir later told his son, “Without colors in tubes, there would be no Cézanne, no Monet, no Pissarro, and no Impressionism.” Beloved Impressionist artists, including, later, Van Gogh, wouldn’t have emerged without exciting, newly synthesized colors and the latest tin paint tube technology.

Take Van Gogh as an example. His famous Sunflowers paintings, featuring beaming yellow sunflowers developed through a rich layering of paint, would have been impossible without newly synthesized chrome yellow, a cheaper contemporary alternative to cadmium yellow.

Van Gogh wrote to his brother Theo in December 1885 about his passion for the latest color innovations:

I am crazy about those two colors, carmine [a red pigment, probably made from a synthetic dye] and cobalt. Cobalt is a divine color, and there is nothing so beautiful for putting atmosphere around things. Carmine is the red of wine, and it is warm and lively like wine. The same with emerald-green. It is bad economics not to use these colors, the same with cadmium.

Importantly, the colors available in Van Gogh’s time were already so abundant, albeit expensive, that he used them directly from the tube. By contrast, a 17th-century artist, or his apprentices, would have to labor night and day to grind pigments and mix them with oil by hand. Had Van Gogh been born in the Middle Ages, his genius would likely never have found the colorful means to express itself.

The inventions continued, and today’s colors are not only cheaper and more varied, but also far safer. Many of the colors used in 19th-century British wallpaper, including the aforementioned Scheele’s green and emerald green, were often laced with arsenic, whose dangers in the home were not yet widely understood. Victorian doctors recorded families falling ill and patients with skin complaints that cleared up once the wallpaper was removed. Workers, such as artificial flower makers who dusted fake leaves with the powder, and painters who worked daily with the pigments (often also made from lead and mercury) fared worse, with many suffering chronic poisoning and death.

In Tulip Fever, ultramarine blue was a luxury reserved for the portrait of a rich merchant’s wife, showing off her wealth and status. This morning, I let my toddler use ultramarine during one of our regular painting sessions. It’s popular to say that the best days of art are behind us. But from the standpoint of availability, cost, and safety, now is the best time in history to be an artist.


  1. Wage estimate based on John Munro’s Antwerp master-mason wage series, scaled to unskilled laborers using Robert Allen’s 2001 wage data.