Listen to the podcast or read the full transcript here.
I’m Marian Tupy, the editor and founder of HumanProgress.org. My guest today is Diego Sánchez de la Cruz, a Spanish economist, author, and one of Spain’s leading advocates of free market reform.
Today, we’ll be talking about his latest book, The Madrid Model: How Freedom and Openness Created an Economic Powerhouse, which examines how 25 years of tax cuts, deregulation, and openness to newcomers helped turn Madrid into one of Europe’s most dynamic regional economies.
Let’s start with the division of powers in Spain. How autonomous is the Community of Madrid in its decision-making?
The Kingdom of Spain is one of the most decentralized countries within the OECD. Regional governments have extensive power to tax and spend. Madrid can set 50 percent of the income tax. It has full power to legislate on inheritance taxes, gift taxes, wealth taxes, and transfer taxes. Regions also run healthcare policy, educational policies, social services, housing, and planning. Even policing is delegated to the region in some areas.
The size here also matters. Spain has some small, successful regions like La Rioja, where some of our best wines come from, but Madrid’s GDP is essentially as large as Portugal’s. We are talking about a significant economic area with significant levels of fiscal and political authority, so Madrid is very good proof that decentralization can work positively.
Let’s now talk about evidence. What is the evidence that Madrid is doing well?
In the mid-1990s, Madrid ranked fifth in the country for GDP per capita, fourth for job creation, and fourth for GDP growth. In other words, there wasn’t much going on in Madrid’s economy.
In the last three decades, however, real GDP growth has averaged 3 percent annually. That is a very high number by European standards, and the rest of Spain has stagnated over the same period. Since the mid-1990s, our region has also created 2 million jobs. The unemployment rate has come down. And this is very impressive because a very significant chunk of the population of Spain has moved to Madrid, as well as many people from Latin America and from other OECD countries. Fifty percent of Madrid’s workforce was not born in Madrid, and yet there has been absolutely no issue in terms of economic integration.
Most notably, we have traditionally been compared with Catalonia, the other Spanish region best known overseas. Catalonia was an economic powerhouse for a long time, but it has fallen behind Madrid. And this is the result of diverging policies. Today, Madrid has more jobs than Catalonia, even though Catalonia has 1 million more inhabitants. Madrid now has a higher GDP than any other territory, including in per capita terms.
What caused that great success in Madrid? What policies were implemented?
In the mid-1990s, there was a clear mandate from voters to stop Madrid from going down the path of socialism, where it had been stuck for the previous 14 years. Madrid was never going to be a poor region, but it was stagnant. That began to change in the mid-1990s, but the real reforms kicked in a few years later when Esperanza Aguirre was elected governor of Madrid. She wanted Madrid to be a business-friendly, investment-friendly magnet for human capital. In essence, an open economy with an open society. She worked with the likes of Pedro Schwartz, who was perhaps one of the most relevant classical liberal thinkers in Spain in the 1970s and 1980s, as well as with Prime Minister Aznar, who was perhaps the most liberalizing leader in the political history of modern Spain.
When she took the reins of the region of Madrid, she cut taxes massively, starting with a wealth tax. She got rid of several income tax brackets. She allowed businesses to open whenever they wanted in terms of business hours and days. She introduced private management in several hospitals, freedom of choice for specialized doctor consultations, and freedom of choice in the educational system, similar to a charter school model.
Aguirre left active politics because she was diagnosed with cancer. But that model stuck for eight years, and the current governor, Isabel Díaz Ayuso, just enacted a series of second-wave reforms. Speaking of Ayuso, she made sure to keep Madrid open throughout the pandemic, which, as you know, was not the norm around the world. She has also enacted sweeping deregulation in several areas. So those two big waves of liberalization have kept the Madrid Model going strong for more than two decades now.
I should mention for our American audience that when we use the word “liberal,” we use it in the European sense. In Spain and in Latin America, “liberal” means somebody who is devoted to freedom and small government, whereas in the United States, that word has a very different connotation.
Okay, so you are not just saying that the economy of Madrid has grown, say, by attracting businesses from the rest of Spain. You are saying that productivity has increased at a faster rate in Madrid than elsewhere, thereby increasing the wages of the workers there, correct?
Yes. Right now, Madrid is home to roughly 15 percent of the national population, but it is attracting 70 percent of the foreign investment. Besides that, although overall business investment in Spain is below where it was before the pandemic, capital formation by businesses in Madrid has kept rising, and that has had a cascading effect on job creation and salaries.
In Spain, the average unemployment rate for the last 40 years has been above 18 percent. Think about that. Everyone would riot in the United States if the unemployment rate were even close to that figure. In Madrid, unemployment is hovering around 7 to 8 percent and keeps falling as the years go by. So, with more investment comes more productivity, and with more productivity comes more job creation and higher salaries. Right now, the average salary of a Madrileño is roughly 10,000 euros higher than in other Spanish regions.
In terms of economic growth, what reforms were the most impactful?
The tax cuts cannot be stressed enough. Spanish politicians seem to forget that while a tax hike can raise revenue, it also erodes the tax base. Madrid has taken the other route. Over the last 15 years, the average household in Madrid has been given back more than 60,000 euros as a result of these tax cuts. The wealth tax was eliminated completely, and the inheritance tax was almost entirely eliminated. Income tax brackets also kick in at higher income levels than in other territories in Spain and Europe.
The second element here has been deregulation. For example—and I’m very proud of this one because I was kind of the intellectual father behind it—we passed the Open Market Law. When you have a constitutional mandate that requires economic activities to be regulated by regions, you can end up with licenses and permits that need to be granted by each individual polity within your state. You have that problem in the United States and in many other territories. But not in Madrid, because Madrid has enacted the Open Market Law, which automatically recognizes any permit or license for any sort of economic activity that has been declared legal by any other territory within Spain. It is estimated that this licensing issue reduces overall output in Spain by 4 percent, but Madrid has turned it into an opportunity. That reform alone has created more than 50,000 jobs per year since it was enacted by making it easier for companies to expand into Madrid.
I was also involved with designing what we call “the line against hyperregulation,” which is essentially an inbox where you can submit your complaints about bureaucracy, red tape, and overregulation. Just listening to citizens and companies has resulted in more than 700 deregulatory measures. I’ve also read recently that Argentina has, in the last few years, incorporated similar reforms, so Madrid has become a deregulatory blueprint for the Hispanic world.
That’s all very exciting.
Tell me, were these two ladies trying to recreate reforms that were happening somewhere else, or was it based on homegrown ideas with the philosophical and economic input of people like you and Pedro Schwartz?
Well, there is a very rich classical liberal and libertarian intellectual movement in Madrid, as well as a very rich conservative movement. Here, conservatives, libertarians, and classical liberals tend to find themselves in alignment. But what’s interesting is that, as people move to Madrid, these ideas now have popular roots. Go tell a Venezuelan who fled his country—and there are hundreds of thousands of them living in Madrid now—that socialism works. They have seen that policy destroy their country, and now they are seeing the success of Madrid.
So inspiration comes from these intellectual circles, but also from regular folks. During the COVID-19 pandemic, Madrid decided not to shut down. The first weeks of lockdown were mandated nationally, but once that was over, Madrid opened up. The entire country was shocked. In the main left-wing paper in Spain, El País, Madrid was described as a bomb of potential virality about to explode. But at the end of the pandemic, Madrid had lower mortality and a smaller fall in economic growth. So it ended positively, and the support for that COVID-19 policy came from regular small business owners who just wanted to keep their jobs and way of life.
I also cannot stress enough the respect we have here in Spain for institutions like the Cato Institute and for our friends in Great Britain. Aguirre was very much a Thatcherite. So it’s a combination of both foreign and homegrown ideas. And while it was initially an intellectual revolution, it has become a popular system. Madrileños like lower taxes; they don’t want to tax the rich, and they don’t want to increase government spending.
What happened to the tax revenue after all these tax cuts? Has the government been able to finance its basic functions?
We have a self-reinforcing cycle here as well. By lowering taxes, we create more economic activity and broaden the tax base. More people move to Madrid, more capital is invested in Madrid, and more businesses are formed in Madrid. This larger tax base generates more revenue. But in Madrid, politicians are not jumping on the Laffer curve to get more money out of taxpayers. They’re actually using that additional revenue to keep lowering taxes.
Madrid is home to just 15 percent of the national population, but more than 50 percent of the high-income individuals. Catalonia is home to 20 percent of the population, but only 20 percent of the high-income individuals. This results in very positive dynamics. Our tax cuts have also reduced the “shadow economy.” During the global financial crisis, many economies in Southern Europe, including Spain, saw that with excessive tax burdens, workers would leave the official economy and enter the shadow economy. By reducing the shadow economy, the tax cuts poured 20 billion euros into regulated economic activities, and that resulted in more tax revenues that then enabled more tax cuts.
And those who would argue that we have starved basic services are absolutely wrong. We have Europe’s best metro system. More than 100 kilometers of metro lines were built under the Madrid Model. On average, Spain doesn’t do well in education, but if Madrid were a separate country, it would rank among the best in the OECD. Madrid is also the European region with the highest life expectancy.
It seems like I should move to Madrid.
Now, we’ve been teasing our listeners with the comparison between Madrid and Catalonia. What’s going on there?
Quite honestly, Catalonia was doing well until the mid-1990s. However, Catalonia chose to venture into one particular area of identity politics, though not perhaps the one you are thinking about right now if you’re an American. It started actually pushing for separatism. Schools became centered around separatist propaganda. Government spending became all about propping up separatist elements, which led to higher taxes. And immigration has not been able to flow easily to Catalonia because a language barrier was created.
The language barrier being that people now have to speak Catalan rather than Spanish?
Yes. You’re kind of forced to speak Catalan if you want to study at university, if you want to apply for a government job, or if you want to work for a private company that deals with the public sector. So migration flows have almost stopped, and right now Catalonia has mainly attracted immigrants from North Africa and Arab countries, which has led to some social tensions. Meanwhile, Madrid, which does have a large population from North Africa and the Middle East, has also attracted people from other Spanish territories, other European and OECD nations, and people from Latin America.
Now, I have a chart in my book showing how Catalonia has stagnated through the last 30 years. Its share of GDP has remained stuck at around 20 percent, while Madrid, again with 15 percent of the population—1 million people fewer than Catalonia—has overtaken Barcelona and Catalonia not just in relative terms but also in absolute terms. So that kind of speaks for itself.
Let’s talk more about immigration, which in Madrid, especially when it comes to immigrants from Latin America, is generally considered to be a success story.
Has it been successful primarily because the cultural difference between a typical Spaniard and somebody from Latin America is relatively small? And is part of the success that immigrants are encouraged to work, whereas immigrants who go to Catalonia don’t necessarily enter the job market?
Very good questions. Madrid does seem to be able to assimilate large numbers of immigrants. In fact, before it became an international magnet for talent, it was a national magnet for talent. Around one quarter of the population in Madrid was born elsewhere in Spain. I myself come from Galicia. Then you have another quarter that was born abroad, and 50 percent were born in Madrid.
The cultural differences are indeed relatively small. There’s a phrase in Spanish that I could translate as “It’s easier to integrate when you pray to the same gods, speak the same language, and dance to the same music.” Shakira left Spain following a highly disputed case with the tax authorities. The tax authorities at the national level are just crazy. But when she was performing here, she was making these very bold claims that Madrid had become the capital of Latin America. And I wouldn’t have it any other way.
It is also a work-based migration. If you are in Catalonia, there are several subsidies and social programs that guarantee you a certain income. None of that exists in Madrid.
So a critic may listen to you and say, “Okay, so you’ve got all of these immigrants coming in, but you don’t have enough housing. House prices are going up.” What’s happening to the housing in Spain?
You mentioned that one of my books can be translated as A Country Without Homes, and that is indeed what we are. The problem there is that we have a Soviet-style mentality towards housing planning, and that has created rising rent and home prices.
Until recently, Madrid was no exception to that rule. However, Madrid has now started to deregulate its housing. Roughly 200,000 housing units are being developed now. I was a big proponent of two large urban transformation projects that have now been unlocked after being caught in red tape for more than 30 years. One of these projects was first proposed 41 years ago, and construction is finally underway.
Now consider this. Madrid may have high rent prices, but it has a supply of homes for rent. Why? Because it did not enact rent control. Catalonia did. Again, the difference couldn’t be more obvious. Catalonia also has very high rent prices, and it has also suffered an 80 percent fall in the housing stock available for rent. So there is a housing problem in Madrid right now, but in Catalonia you have the same problem, along with an 80 percent smaller housing supply thanks to rent controls.
What was the reaction of the Spanish central government to what is happening in Madrid? Have they been helpful or have they been harmful?
The national government has definitely been harmful. It has regularly taken more and more money out of the Madrid region and poured more and more money into Catalonia. Even worse than that, the national government has gone to the courts to try and stop certain tax cuts. It’s gone to the courts to try to stop Madrid’s strategy against COVID-19. The national government is also trying to roll back Madrid’s abolition of the wealth tax, despite the fact that it is under regional authority.
I think the best thing the central government could do—I’m going to sound very much like an American conservative here—is just get out of the way. That would be more than enough. We have a well-designed decentralized system if you let it work.
I know that you believe the European states have enough autonomy to undertake deregulation and liberalization. You don’t believe that the European Union is that much of an obstacle. But is there any reform that you would love to see at the European level?
Stop the nonsense with the Green New Deal. Everything around the Green New Deal, the Pacto Verde, as we call it in Spanish, has done a lot of damage to European industry, and there’s no way that national governments can curtail a regulation that is meant to be applied at the European level.
On the other hand, I’ve done this crazy project of analyzing every law that has been approved in Spain since 2004. That’s why I’m wearing glasses; I’ve essentially lost half my vision doing this. But one thing I’ve learned is that very often national governments will take a European directive that calls on them to enact some sort of regulation, a minimal amount in most cases, and then implement a very interventionist plan that adds several unrequired layers of legislation. So yes, I would roll back many of the excesses that we’ve seen at the EU level, but national governments do have a lot of leeway to act.
What about the precautionary principle? How damaging is that to European innovation?
I will give you one simple example that sums it all up. We have created in Spain an agency to regulate artificial intelligence. We don’t have any artificial intelligence companies to begin with. They are regulating something that doesn’t even exist. It’s the economic abortion of unborn industries; all of this innovation and dynamism and economic output that could be working for our benefit is left unrealized because of this approach.
Well, you’ve been extraordinarily generous with your time. Once again, today I was talking to Diego Sánchez de la Cruz, who has a new book out, The Madrid Model: How Freedom and Openness Created an Economic Powerhouse. I recommend it.