fbpx
01 / 05
Centers of Progress, Pt. 1: Jericho (Agriculture)

Blog Post | Economic Growth

Centers of Progress, Pt. 1: Jericho (Agriculture)

Neolithic Jericho was the site of two decisive events in the history of civilization: permanent settlement and the beginnings of agriculture.

Today marks the launch of a new series of articles by HumanProgress.org called Centers of Progress. Where does progress happen? The story of civilization is in many ways the story of the city. It is the city that has helped to create and define the modern world. This bi-weekly column will give a short overview of urban centers that were the sites of pivotal advances in culture, economics, politics, technology, etc.

Our first Center of Progress is Jericho. Jericho is thought by many scholars to be the worlds oldest city. It was first settled sometime around 9000 BC. The people who lived in Jericho and surrounding areas may have been among the first humans to give up their hunter-gatherer ways, domesticate plants and become farmers.

The invention of agriculture, often called the First Agricultural Revolution or the Neolithic Revolution, was a decisive turning point in our species’ history. It dramatically changed the way that we live. By producing a surplus of food that could be stored for difficult times ahead or traded for other goods, agriculture ultimately allowed for far greater prosperity than hunting and gathering ever could.

Today, Jericho is a tourist-oriented city in the Jordan River Valley and is frequented by religious pilgrims and history buffs. It is relatively small, with a population of just over 20,000 people. The city is located in a natural oasis in the desert, thus earning its nickname in the Hebrew Bible—the City of Palm Trees. The city is home to various cafes selling shawarma and falafel, as well as many historic ruins. Jericho is also the site of near-constant archeological digs, as we try to deepen our knowledge of the citys past.

If you were to visit Neolithic Jericho, you may have been able to observe two decisive events in the history of civilization: permanent settlement and the beginnings of agriculture.

Imagine a group of hunter-gatherers—dubbed Natufians” by todays archeologists—walking through the wilderness. They would have carried hunting weapons such as spears, and they would have worn leather made from the hides of mountain gazelles and beaded jewelry made of gazelle bones. They would have carried food and supplies in baskets and animal skins. They would also have had domesticated dogs walking alongside them, perhaps looking something like the modern-day basenji hound.

You would have seen them coming upon a natural oasis bursting with freshwater springs in the middle of the wilderness and settling down to rest. You would have watched this group of hunter-gatherers coming to a momentous decision as they resolved, perhaps after some spirited discussion in a long-dead language, to build a permanent camp at the oasis and end their nomadic wanderings.

Of course, the decision was probably gradual, with the Natufians camping out at the oasis for longer and longer periods each year, until the settlement became their home year-round. But at some point, the decision was made to remain there permanently. In any case, the Natufians built a number of semi-subterranean oval-shaped stone dwellings to form a village that would grow into the worlds first city. Thus the story of Jericho began.

The first people to inhabit what would become Jericho had long survived by hunting animals such as gazelles, and eating wild cereals and other wild plants. But a shift in the climate, which became less rainy and more desert-like, may have helped to prompt a change in the Natufian survival strategy.

How did that happen? Maybe the Natufians noticed that edible plants sprouted in places where those plants’ seeds had been scattered before. Perhaps inspired by that observation, an enterprising individual (or multiple individuals) must have, at some point, proposed deliberately planting the seeds of the plants that the Natufians ate. When the Natufians began to plant seeds intentionally, they set humanity on a new course.

The Natufians are often called the first farmers. Although there is no expert consensus on precisely where in the Fertile Crescent agriculture first appeared, Jericho was certainly among the earliest communities to practice agriculture. The oldest archaeological remains of domesticated barley, rye and early forms of wheat are found in human Neolithic sites in the Fertile Crescent, such as the Natufian settlement where Jericho is today. Evidence of domesticated figs has also been found near Jericho dating to around 9400 BC.

The worlds first farmers were patient and innovative. Consider wheat. They discovered how to selectively breed wild emmer grass so that the plants seeds would not fall off of its stalks when the grass became ripe, making collection of the seeds far easier. They used the seeds to make bread, and what started as just another kind of grass, gradually became what we now know as wheat. Today, according to Yale University, twenty percent of the worlds total calorie consumption comes from wheat.

Researchers disagree as to how much credit ought to be given to the conscious efforts of the early farmers. “One controversy in this area is about the extent to which ancient peoples knew they were domesticating crops,” noted University of Sheffield plant scientist Colin Osborne. “Did they know they were breeding domestication characteristics into crops, or did these characteristics just evolve as the first farmers sowed wild plants into cultivated soil, and tended and harvested them?” he continued.

In addition to bread, the Natufians also enjoyed beer and some researchers believe that the production of alcoholic beverages made from fermented cereals may have served as one of the motivations underlying early agriculture.

Whatever their motivation, the first Jerichoans became farmers, and were thus able to produce enough food to eventually leave their old hunter-gatherer lifestyle behind. Selectively breeding plants would prove to be a painstakingly slow process, and perhaps for centuries the people of Jericho may have continued to supplement their agricultural food production with hunting and gathering.

As agriculture advanced, the people still hunted gazelles and other game animals, but the grains they planted, harvested and stored yearly increased their food security. One day, there was no longer any need to forage for wild plants, beginning a new chapter in human history.

Over the centuries, the residents of Jericho became increasingly adept at farming. The Jerichoans went on to cultivate many other plants and develop an irrigation system, and their harvests grew larger. They soon had enough food to store for lean times and to trade. But with such productivity came a danger—the threat that nearby nomadic tribes would raid the city and rob Jerichos granaries with their large stores of food.

To fend off raiders, the people of Jericho built the oldest known protective wall in the world, perhaps dating to around 8000 BC. At that point, Jerichos population had probably reached 2,000 people or so. For perspective, that’s about as many people as the current population of the rural town of Victor, Idaho. For its time, however, Jericho must have felt like a bustling metropolis. (Recall that there were fewer than 10 million people in the entire world back then, roughly equivalent to the current population of Portugal).

Producing a surplus of food allowed for some specialization of economic activities: not everyone had to be a farmer, freeing people to pursue other projects. The wall’s construction could not have been accomplished without some degree of specialization. The stone wall stood over 11 feet high, and in addition to defending the city, the wall may also have served to protect the city from floods.

There is some evidence that the walls accompanying 28-foot-high cone-shaped stone tower, also built around 8000 BC, served a symbolic purpose rather than a practical one. The tower is not well-positioned to serve as a defensive lookout. But computer models show that back when the tower was built, the nearby mountains would cast a shadow on it just as the sun set on the longest day of the year—the summer solstice. The shadow would fall precisely on the tower and then spread out to cover all of ancient Jericho.

So, the tower may have served as a warning: its growing shadow let the people of Jericho know that the days ahead were about to start becoming shorter and the nights longer. Agricultural activities such as planting and harvesting are intimately linked to different seasons in the year, and so, to the largely agrarian community of Jericho, marking the summer solstice likely held great significance. The solstice may have been observed as a day of importance, whether as a celebratory festival or a day of solemnity.

The tower also may have symbolized power or authority. Transitioning from hunting and gathering to becoming an agricultural society entailed a transformation in how people related to one another: whereas hunter-gatherer tribes tended to be egalitarian (i.e., lacking in hierarchy), the more specialized and complex society that emerged in Jericho brought with it a new set of social power dynamics. Grave sites show that the first Jerichoans observed differences in rank, with some individuals buried alongside valuable goods such as shell jewelry and others occupying simpler graves.

“This was a time when hierarchy began and leadership was established,” according to Tel Aviv University archeologist Ran Barkai, one of the researchers behind the discovery of the connection between the Tower of Jericho and the summer solstice. “We believe this tower [by acting as a symbol of power and authority] was one of the mechanisms to motivate people to take part in a communal lifestyle,” he continued.

Today, Jericho is perhaps best-known due to the role it played in Biblical times. It is the place that the ancient Israelites are purported to have conquered in 1400 BC, after escaping from slavery in Egypt. The well-known song about the Battle of Jericho, covered by musical icons ranging from Bing Crosby to Elvis Presley, was first composed in the 19th-century United States by enslaved African-Americans. The songs subject, about a previously enslaved people triumphant in battle, and its chorus, proclaiming that Jerichos walls came tumbling down,” both alluded to the songwriters’ own desire for freedom.

Thus the city of Jericho became a symbol of freedom in popular culture many thousands of years after that city helped to free humanity from foraging for food in the wilderness. The transition to agriculture was likely a difficult and patience-testing process, upending the Natufians’ previous way of life and altering their social structure, but the payoff has been a level of food security beyond what our hunter-gatherer ancestors could have imagined.

For being the worlds oldest city and possibly the birthplace of agriculture, Neolithic-era Jericho deserves to be recognized as our first Center of Progress.

Blog Post | Human Development

1,000 Bits of Good News You May Have Missed in 2023

A necessary balance to the torrent of negativity.

Reading the news can leave you depressed and misinformed. It’s partisan, shallow, and, above all, hopelessly negative. As Steven Pinker from Harvard University quipped, “The news is a nonrandom sample of the worst events happening on the planet on a given day.”

So, why does Human Progress feature so many news items? And why did I compile them in this giant list? Here are a few reasons:

  • Negative headlines get more clicks. Promoting positive stories provides a necessary balance to the torrent of negativity.
  • Statistics are vital to a proper understanding of the world, but many find anecdotes more compelling.
  • Many people acknowledge humanity’s progress compared to the past but remain unreasonably pessimistic about the present—not to mention the future. Positive news can help improve their state of mind.
  • We have agency to make the world better. It is appropriate to recognize and be grateful for those who do.

Below is a nonrandom sample (n = ~1000) of positive news we collected this year, separated by topic area. Please scroll, skim, and click. Or—to be even more enlightened—read this blog post and then look through our collection of long-term trends and datasets.

Agriculture

Aquaculture

Farming robots and drones

Food abundance

Genetic modification

Indoor farming

Lab-grown produce

Pollination

Other innovations

Conservation and Biodiversity

Big cats

Birds

Turtles

Whales

Other comebacks

Forests

Reefs

Rivers and lakes

Surveillance and discovery

Rewilding and conservation

De-extinction

Culture and tolerance

Gender equality

General wellbeing

LGBT

Treatment of animals

Energy and natural Resources

Fission

Fusion

Fossil fuels

Other energy

Recycling and resource efficiency

Resource abundance

Environment and pollution

Climate change

Disaster resilience

Air pollution

Water pollution

Growth and development

Education

Economic growth

Housing and urbanization

Labor and employment

Health

Cancer

Disability and assistive technology

Dementia and Alzheimer’s

Diabetes

Heart disease and stroke

Other non-communicable diseases

HIV/AIDS

Malaria

Other communicable diseases

Maternal care

Fertility and birth control

Mental health and addiction

Weight and nutrition

Longevity and mortality 

Surgery and emergency medicine

Measurement and imaging

Health systems

Other innovations

Freedom

    Technology 

    Artificial intelligence

    Communications

    Computing

    Construction and manufacturing

    Drones

    Robotics and automation

    Autonomous vehicles

    Transportation

    Other innovations

    Science

    AI in science

    Biology

    Chemistry and materials

      Physics

      Space

      Violence

      Crime

      War

      Yahoo Singapore | Infrastructure

      Singapore’s “Long Island” Project Aims to Fix Rising Sea Levels

      “Singapore is studying a significant transformation along its East Coast, with plans to reclaim three tracts of land known as Long Island.

      This endeavour spans approximately 800 hectares—twice the size of Marina Bay—and aims to address the threats posed by rising sea levels and inland flooding in the region.”

      From Yahoo Singapore.

      Blog Post | Infrastructure

      Centers of Progress, Pt. 35: Agra (Architecture)

      The Indo-Mughal architecture of Agra represents a high point of human achievement in the arts.

      Today marks the thirty-fifth installment in a series of articles by HumanProgress.org called Centers of Progress. Where does progress happen? The story of civilization is in many ways the story of the city. It is the city that has helped to create and define the modern world. This bi-weekly column will give a short overview of urban centers that were the sites of pivotal advances in culture, economics, politics, technology, etc.

      The thirty-fifth Center of Progress is Agra during the city’s golden age at the time of the Mughal Empire (1526–1857). In Agra, different cultures converged to create what many believe is humanity’s greatest architectural achievement: the Taj Mahal (constructed 1631–1653).

      Located on a broad plain on the banks of the Yamuna River in the Indian state of Uttar Pradesh, Agra is home to roughly 1.6 million people. The city is known for its leather goods, handwoven carpets, stone handicrafts, and distinct red sandstone. It is also known for its Mughlai cuisine, which has evolved considerably from the days when Mughal emperors dined on food flecked with silver. As a major road and rail junction, as well as a prong of India’s “Golden Triangle” tourist circuit, Agra is a transportation hub. Tourism is a major factor in Agra’s economy, and the city contains two UNESCO World Heritage Sites: the Agra Fort and the Taj Mahal.

      The area where Agra now stands has attracted notice since ancient times. Agra is referenced in the ancient Sanskrit epic poem the Mahabharata, which mentions “the forest of Agravana.” But it was the famed Greek scholar Claudius Ptolemy, who lived in Alexandria nearly four thousand miles away, who provided history’s first recorded use of the name “Agra.” “[I]t is easy to recognize the Yamuna, the river which after passing Delhi, Mathura, Agra, and other places, joins the Ganges,” Ptolemy noted in his work Geographia (The Geography), published in AD 150. 

      Despite these ancient roots, according to tradition, Agra was founded in the year 1504, when Sultan Sikandar Lodi made it the capital from which he and later his son, Sultan Ibrahim Lodi, ruled over the Delhi Sultanate.

      But Agra truly rose to prominence under the Mughal Empire, founded by the Uzbek-born chieftain Babur (1483–1530) in 1526, who conquered Agra and took the younger Lodi’s throne. He had the Ram Bagh, or the Garden of Relaxation, laid out on the banks of the river Yamuna, where it remains as the oldest extant Mughal garden. Babur’s daughter-in-law Empress Bega Begum began the dynasty’s tradition of palatial tombs on the Indian subcontinent in 1558 when she commissioned an elaborate final resting place for her husband, Babur’s son, the second Mughal emperor Humayun. Created by architects from Persia and representing the first garden-tomb in India, this impressive structure in Delhi would soon be dwarfed by the tombs of Agra. 

      The empire greatly expanded under Humayun’s son, the third Mughal emperor, Akbar the Great (1542–1605). Akbar focused on both territorial and commercial expansion, conquering land and strengthening trade ties with neighboring realms. Agra’s population swelled under Akbar, reaching as many as 800,000 people.

      Akbar redesigned and raised the towering ramparts of the Agra Fort and commissioned the 15-story-tall Buland Darwaza, or “Door of Victory,” just outside of Agra, which remains the highest gateway in the world. Akbar was, for his era, unusually tolerant of other religions. He repealed the customary tax on non-Muslims (the jizyah) and ended the death penalty for de-converting from Islam to Hinduism. He created a religious institution known as the Ibādat Khāna (“House of Worship”), which encouraged interfaith philosophical and theological debates.

      Akbar also personally engaged in a radical experiment in religious syncretism, promulgating what some historians describe as a spiritual training program and others call a new religion. The movement, called Din-i Ilahi, attempted to reconcile and merge Islam, Hinduism, and Zoroastrianism and incorporated elements from Christianity, Jainism, and Buddhism. Akbar sought to promote what he saw as the best aspects of these different faiths – such as Hinduism’s encouragement of vegetarianism and Islam’s central tenet of Tawhid, or monotheism. Many of his Muslim contemporaries considered the emperor a heretic (as do many Muslims today), but Akbar’s unusual views helped increase his popularity among his many Hindu subjects.

      Akbar took up various native customs, participated in Diwali and other local festivals, and showed an enthusiasm for Sanskrit literature, which he had translated. His son Jahangir and grandson Shah Jahan also would not eat beef in deference to Hindu beliefs. Multiculturalism continued to define the Mughal Empire for centuries after Akbar’s death and influenced the architecture of Agra.

      Akbar’s tomb lies in Sikandra on the outskirts of Agra. Constructed from the local deep red sandstone and decorated with beautiful calligraphy and geometric patterns, the tomb combines Muslim and native Indian art styles. The tomb is noted for its four white marble chhatri (dome-shaped pavilion)-topped minarets, which may have inspired similar features in the Taj Mahal. The body of Akbar’s favorite wife, Mariam, rests in another elaborate tomb, also in Sikandra.

      But Agra’s most prominent tomb, besides the Taj Mahal, is the Tomb of I’timad-ud-Daulah. Nicknamed the “Baby Taj,” it is a direct forerunner to the Taj Mahal. I’timad-ud-Daulah was a Persian-born Mughal official who served as Prime Minister under Akbar’s and Mariam’s son, Emperor Jahangir (1569–1627), and whose daughter married Jahangir. Built between 1622 and 1628, the tomb signifies an evolution from the first phase of monumental Mughal architecture–primarily built from red sandstone, as in Humayun’s and Akbar’s tombs–to a new phase, with perhaps an even more pronounced mixing of different architectural traditions. The choice of white marble may have been influenced by Hindu practices “set out in the Vishnudharmottara Purana [a sacred Sanskrit text], which recommended white stone for buildings for the Brahmins.” 

      Intercultural synthesis was a key characteristic of Agra’s Mughal architecture, which mixes Indian, Persian, and Turkish styles, among others. Islam more broadly has a tradition of syncretizing different architectural styles, such as in the Mosque-Cathedral of Córdoba and the Royal Alcázar in Seville. While Muslim architects likely drew inspiration from their faith—a famous hadith says, “God is beautiful and loves beauty”—they were also constrained by it: a prominent interpretation of Islam prohibits depicting people or animals. As a result, Muslim artists often avoided sculpting or painting people and animals (with notable exceptions such as the “Persian miniature” painting tradition), instead developing expertise in calligraphy, poetry, and art based around abstract geometric patterns. These aniconic designs are among the most distinguishing features of Islamic art and decorate objects of all types, from carpets to stoneware. Alongside calligraphic inscriptions, they also prominently adorn the surfaces of monumental Islamic architecture. Even these distinctive patterns, though, are ultimately the result of cultural intermixing. According to the Metropolitan Museum of Art:

      While geometric ornamentation may have reached a pinnacle in the Islamic world, the sources for both the shapes and the intricate patterns already existed in late antiquity among the Greeks, Romans, and Sasanians in Iran. Islamic artists appropriated key elements from the classical tradition, then complicated and elaborated upon them in order to invent a new form of decoration that stressed the importance of unity and order.

      Continuing the virtuous cycle of artistic intercultural borrowing, many notable Islamic geometric designs–like arabesques, or interlaced tendril patterns, and Girih, or angular knotlike patterns–inspired Christian artists in Italy and elsewhere. Arabesque is, in fact, a French word derived from the Italian term arabesco, meaning “in the Arab style.” Artistic inspiration flowed in both directions, with Muslim and Christian artists and architects continuously borrowing ideas from one another. For example, the elegant pietra dura or parchin kari jewel-inlaying technique, mainly developed in Renaissance-era Florence with the generous patronage of the Medici family, was used prominently in Mughal artworks. Agra’s “Baby Taj” made ample use of that inlay technique, but the most elegant use of pietra dura in architectural history is widely considered to be in the Taj Mahal itself.

      The Taj Mahal was commissioned by Jahangir’s son, the grieving Emperor Shah Jahan (1592–1666), for his favorite wife, Mumtaz Mahal (1593–1631), meaning “Jewel of the Palace.” “Taj Mahal” is derived from her name. While Shah Jahan had two other wives, they were consequences of political marriages, and he largely ignored the former. The emperor was famously inseparable from Mumtaz Mahal, who accompanied him on his imperial travels and even his military campaigns. 

      Tragically, even an emperor’s family was not safe from the horrifically high rates of child mortality and maternal mortality at the time. Mumtaz Mahal died at age thirty-eight from birth-related complications. Only half of her fourteen children survived to adulthood, with four dying in infancy, one dying at age one and a half, one dying of smallpox at age three, and another dying of smallpox at age seven. 

      According to legend, as Mumtaz Mahal lay dying, she bound her husband with a promise to build her the most beautiful mausoleum known to man.

      The Taj Mahal was built in twenty-two years by over twenty thousand artisans, some summoned from as far as Italy and Persia. The prominent calligraphic adornments are thought to be the work of Amanat Ali Khan Shirazi, the Persian brother of Shah Jahan’s prime minister. Ran Mahal, from Kashmir, the northernmost region of the Indian subcontinent, is believed to have designed the complex’s magnificent gardens. One controversial theory claims that a Venetian jeweler living in Agra, Geronimo Veroneo, played a part in the design of the Taj Mahal. The main architect was likely Ustad Ahmad Lahouri, a Persian who may have hailed from modern-day Pakistan or Afghanistan. Ustad Isa from Shiraz in the Safavid Empire (modern-day Iran), who may have also been part Turkish, is credited with the site plan. Shah Jahan himself played an active role in the Taj Mahal’s design, making “appropriate alterations to whatever the skillful architects had designed after considerable thought and would ask the architects competent questions.”

      The Taj Mahal’s building materials also came from near and far, with its famous white marble brought from the neighboring province of Rajasthan, the jasper from Punjab, and the jade and crystal adornments from China. Lapis-lazuli, cornelian, mother of pearl, agate, and emerald were also among the precious gems and stones used in the Taj Mahal’s design. The building is thought to have cost around 1 billion 2020 U.S. dollars. Peter Mundy, an Englishman living in Agra at the time, described the construction this way (with spelling modernized for readability):

      This King is now building a sepulcher for his late deceased Queen Taj [Mumtaz] Mahal… He intends it shall excel all other[s]… The building is begun and goes on with excessive labor and cost, prosecuted with extraordinary diligence, gold and silver … and marble.

      There is widespread international agreement that the Taj Mahal represents a pinnacle of architectural beauty. Type “most beautiful building” into an internet search engine, and chances are the Taj Mahal will appear. The Google Arts & Culture website on the Taj Mahal says, “It is considered the most beautiful building ever constructed.” The Encyclopedia Britannica says, “One of the most beautiful structural compositions in the world, the Taj Mahal is also one of the world’s most iconic monuments.” National Geographic similarly notes, “The Taj Mahal is widely considered one of the most beautiful buildings ever created.” The Metropolitan Museum of Art concurs, counting the Taj Mahal “among the most beautiful buildings in the world.”

      The Taj Mahal’s famed tomb forms the centerpiece of a 42-acre complex, which also includes a mosque and a guest house. These architectural wonders stand in a sprawling garden enclosed on three sides by ornate domed and crenelated red sandstone walls. The tomb’s main dome is nearly 115 feet high. The palace-like structure is famed for its proportionality, sumptuous attention to detail, and symmetry. It looks the same from all sides, except the one facing the Yamuna River, which was the mourning king’s entrance–he would take a barge across the river to pay his respects to his late wife. The acoustics of the Taj Mahal’s interior are notable, having, according to the monument’s official government website, “a reverberation time (the time taken from when a noise is made until all of its echoes have died away) of 28 seconds providing an atmosphere where the words of the Hafiz, as they prayed for the soul of Mumtaz, would linger in the air.” (A Hafiz is someone who has memorized the Quran).

      Shah Jahan claimed the Taj Mahal’s beauty made “the sun and the moon shed tears.” He is said to have attempted to make the tomb an earthly replica of the palace he believed Mumtaz would inhabit in paradise. The Indian Nobel Laureate Rabindranath Tagore described the Taj Mahal as a “teardrop on the cheek of eternity.” The Persian poet Kalim Kashani wrote, “It is a [piece of] heaven of the color of dawn’s bright face, because from top to bottom and inside out it is of marble… The eye can mistake it for a cloud.” The Taj Mahal has also been called “a poem in stone.” It is also one of the New Seven Wonders of the World.

      The last of the Mughal rulers to commission notable architecture was Shah Jahan and Mumtaz Mahal’s son Aurangzeb (1618–1707), who was not especially interested in architecture but had two impressive mosques built as well as the Bibi Ka Maqbara (“Tomb of the Lady”) for his wife–which closely resembles the Taj Mahal. Rather than build a separate tomb for his father, Aurangzeb had Shah Jahan interred next to Mumtaz Mahal. (Mumtaz Mahal lies in the center of the Taj Mahal, and Shah Jahan’s asymmetrical placement to her side suggests the tomb was originally meant to hold Mumtaz Mahal alone). Agra’s architectural wonders continue to attract thousands of visitors from around the world each year.

      Taj Mahal, Agra, India

      While tastes differ, and some may favor different architectural styles—perhaps preferring the Gothic arches of Westminster Abbey in London or the Art Nouveau masterpieces of Antoni Gaudí in Barcelona—there is little doubt that Agra is home to some of the most impressive and visually pleasing architecture ever constructed. Much like the Renaissance paintings of Florence or the classical symphonies of Vienna, the Indo-Mughal architecture of Agra represents a high point of human achievement in the arts. Agra demonstrates the artistic potential of intercultural borrowing and exchange. It is for these reasons that 17th-century Agra can claim its place as our 35th Center of Progress.