01 / 05
We’re Living in a Split-Screen America

Blog Post | Communications

We’re Living in a Split-Screen America

The evolution from broadcast news to personalized feeds has fractured how we see the world, but progress is possible.

Summary: Americans once shared a common media landscape, but the rise of personalized digital feeds has splintered that reality into partisan echo chambers. Social platforms now amplify outrage, reinforce tribal instincts, and erode agreement on basic facts. While there is no easy fix, reforms in design, digital literacy, and cultural norms offer hope for a more truthful and united public discourse.


“And that’s the way it is.” At least, that’s the way it was. When Walter Cronkite closed his nightly broadcasts with those words, America was a foreign country. At the height of broadcast news, Americans had differences of opinion but agreed on a basic set of facts about what was going on in the country and the world. Anchors like Cronkite, voted in 1972 by Democrats and Republicans alike as the most trusted man in America, aimed to be impartial and to win bipartisan credibility. But as partisan cable news and talk radio came to prominence in the 1990s, basic agreement on the facts began to erode. And with the rise of social media, it splintered entirely.

Platforms like Facebook, YouTube, TikTok, and Twitter personalize content to maximize engagement (time spent on an app, posts liked and shared), showing you what you want to see. That reinforces users’ existing beliefs and limits exposure to opposing views. Strikingly, a Meta-commissioned study of 208 million users during the 2020 U.S. election cycle showed that liberals and conservatives on Facebook encountered almost entirely non-overlapping news sources. Once a social media user spends time looking at political content on one of these platforms, he or she is fed more and more of the same. Far from the broadcasts of the mid-century, modern news is delivered via increasingly bespoke “narrowcast.”

This political siloing is not trivial. Americans now inhabit split-screen realities. In one 2023 Gallup poll, 90 percent of Republicans believed crime was rising, while 60 percent of Democrats believed it was falling. On climate change, a 2021 survey showed a 56-point partisan gap in beliefs about whether humans have a serious impact on the climate system (compared to a 16-point gap in 2001). In 2024, 44 percent of Democrats rated the national economy as “excellent or good,” compared to only 13 percent of Republicans, despite the same underlying economic conditions. The gap wasn’t driven by personal finances, but by partisan interpretations of identical economic indicators. These are not differences of opinion; they are incommensurable beliefs about the state of the world.

But platforms don’t just feed us headlines that align with our politics. They also bait our strongest emotions. In 2017, Facebook began weighting “angry” reactions five times more heavily than “likes” when floating posts to the top of our feeds. That same year, a study found that each additional moral-emotional word in a tweet (think “shameful,” “detestable”, “evil”) significantly increased the likelihood of it being shared and reshared.

This platform design calls up ancient instincts. Humans evolved to detect threats to the coalition, to signal our group loyalty, and to rally allies against rivals. A tweet calling someone “abhorrent” isn’t just an opinion; it’s a tribal call to action. And because these platforms so reliably elicit our ire and impel us to spread it to others, they’ve become outrage engines.

They create sealed chambers that echo our anger, where contrary evidence is unlikely to penetrate. Carl Sagan now sounds prescient when he warned in 1995 of a future where Americans, embedded in an information economy, would become “unable to distinguish between what feels good and what’s true,” leaving society vulnerable to illusion and manipulation.

And the consequences of the outrage engines don’t stop at our borders. In 2016, Russian operatives used fake personas on Facebook and Twitter to spread inflammatory memes targeting both liberals and conservatives. They didn’t need to hack anything. They simply exploited an information ecosystem already optimized for spreading partisan outrage.

What can be done? There is no single fix, but meaningful improvements are possible.

In a randomized study, older adults who received just one hour of digital literacy training from MediaWise improved their ability to tell false headlines from real ones by 21 percentage points. When Twitter added a prompt asking users if they wanted to read an article before retweeting it, people were 40 percent more likely to click through to the article before sharing it impulsively.

Choice helps too. In one study, switching users from a feed that had been personalized by the algorithm to one that showed posts in chronological order measurably increased their exposure to content across the political aisle. While it may not be a silver bullet, giving users the ability to choose their feed structure, including which algorithm to use, allows for opportunities to be exposed to contrary opinions and to peer outside the echo chamber.

But deeper change is cultural. A compelling case has been made that human reasoning evolved not to uncover objective truth, but to persuade others, to justify our own ideas, and to win arguments. That is why the habits of sound reasoning must be cultivated through norms that prize truth over tribal loyalty, deliberation over impulsivity, and the ability to make the best case for opposing views in order to oppose them on their merits.

This isn’t a call for censorship or government control of the news, nor is it a plea to go back to three-network broadcasting. The democratization of media has brought real benefits, including broader participation in public discourse and greater scrutiny of powerful institutions. But it has also made public life more combustible and has manufactured disagreements about factual questions. In a competition for attention, platforms are designed to maximize time spent on them. That means elevating content that provokes strong emotional responses, especially outrage, and targeting it toward the users most likely to react. The more incendiary the content, the more likely it is to hold us captivated.

What we are witnessing is not a failure of the market, but a particularly efficient version of it, albeit one that optimizes for attention, not accuracy. Personalized feeds, algorithmic curation, and viral content are giving people more of what they want. And yet, many Americans say they are dissatisfied with the result. In a 2023 Pew survey, 86 percent of U.S. adults said they believe Democrats and Republicans are more focused on fighting each other than solving real problems, and respondents across party lines cited political polarization as the biggest problem with the political system.

While online outrage bubbles may not qualify as a market failure in the technical sense, they are clearly a civic problem worth confronting. An information ecosystem optimized for attention rather than accuracy will reliably amplify division and distrust, even while giving users more of what they like to see and share. The incentives are working as designed, but the outcome is a fragmented public unable to agree on the real state of the world. If democracy depends on a shared understanding of basic facts of the matter, then reckoning with these tradeoffs is well worth our much-demanded attention.

Blog Post | Innovation

You Don’t Have to Like Elon Musk to Value What He Builds

Society benefits from extraordinary innovators, even when their personalities make them difficult to tolerate.

Summary: Technological progress often comes from unconventional people. Elon Musk’s abrasive conduct has made him a polarizing figure, but his companies have helped cut rocket launch costs, expand internet access, and make electric cars mainstream. Some traits that drive ambitious breakthroughs may also make their creators difficult to work with. Holding innovators accountable for harmful conduct need not mean dismissing their accomplishments or demanding agreeable personalities.


Last Thursday, Tesla demonstrated a prototype Roadster capable of briefly flying through the air. Elon Musk’s AI company, now part of SpaceX, recently introduced Grok Bot, autonomous agents that run on a shared persistent cloud computer and that can collaborate with one another and execute scheduled tasks in users’ apps while they are offline.

Meanwhile, SpaceX continues developing Starship, the largest rocket ever built, with the ambition of making space travel cheaper and more routine.

On Friday, Alex Gibney’s nearly four-hour documentary, Musk, opened nationwide. The film presents Musk as a deeply flawed man whose wealth and power have become dangerous. There is plenty of evidence for the first part of that judgment. But the documentary raises a larger question. How much offensiveness should society tolerate from people who push the technological frontier forward?

My answer is quite a lot.

Musk insults journalists, politicians, and critics. He promotes conspiracy theories, makes extravagant promises, and sometimes treats employees harshly. His interventions in politics have alienated former admirers, including environmentalists who once championed Tesla. His management of X has angered advertisers and free-speech advocates alike. His involvement with the Department of Government Efficiency antagonized many, and government auditors questioned its claimed savings. He can be arrogant, impulsive, vindictive, juvenile, and spectacularly rude.

But Musk’s failings should be weighed against his contributions to human progress.

Consider SpaceX. When Musk founded the company in 2002, rockets were largely disposable. SpaceX developed boosters that could land and fly again, helping reduce the cost of reaching orbit and enabling more frequent launches. Its Dragon spacecraft restored America’s ability to launch astronauts from U.S. soil after the space shuttle program was retired. Its Falcon rockets transformed the satellite-launch industry. Starship could eventually make it possible to transport much larger payloads at lower cost, opening new opportunities for scientific research, manufacturing, and exploration.

Perhaps SpaceX’s most consequential achievement for ordinary people is Starlink. By the end of 2025, the satellite internet service had more than 9 million customers across more than 155 countries and markets. In remote communities where laying fiber-optic cables is prohibitively expensive, Starlink provides access to online education, telemedicine, banking, and commerce. Rural schools in Alaska have used it to improve educational access. After Hurricane Helene devastated parts of the American Southeast in 2024, emergency responders deployed Starlink terminals to restore communications.

In Ukraine, Starlink and its military counterpart, Starshield, have been especially important. Russian attacks destroyed or disrupted much of the country’s communications infrastructure. Satellite connections helped Ukrainian soldiers coordinate operations, operate drones, and communicate with commanders. Civilians also benefited from access to the internet when conventional networks failed. 

The recent restrictions on Ukraine’s Starshield service illustrate the dangers of relying heavily on a single provider, as Musk has blamed the disruption on the White House and reporting over the weekend suggested it was Musk’s idea. Such uncertainty strengthens the case for competition and clear rules governing essential infrastructure. It also demonstrates just how valuable the underlying technology has become.

Musk’s contribution to electric vehicles has been similarly consequential. He did not invent the electric car, joining Tesla after its 2003 founding. But he helped transform electric vehicles from a niche product into a serious competitor to gasoline-powered automobiles. Before Tesla, EVs were often viewed as slow or purely utilitarian. By prioritizing high performance, cutting-edge technology, and sleek design, Musk helped make electric cars highly desirable and genuinely “cool.” Established automakers responded with massive investments of their own. Because of this massive shift in consumer demand and industry standards, it is fair to argue that Musk has done more than any other individual to accelerate the global transition away from the internal combustion engine. Tesla also helped advance battery technology and large-scale electricity storage.

Neuralink, Musk’s neurotechnology company, is developing implantable brain-computer interfaces designed to translate neural activity into digital commands. By using thousands of microscopic electrodes surgically implanted into the brain, the device has recently enabled individuals with severe paralysis to control computers, move cursors, and play video games using only their thoughts. While the technology remains experimental, its potential medical benefits, such as restoring communication, mobility, and independence for patients with severe neurological conditions, are considerable.

Not every Musk venture will succeed. Grok Bot remains an emerging technology. The flying Roadster is an engineering demonstration rather than a practical transportation solution. Starship faces substantial technical challenges. Musk’s ambitious timelines have often proved unreliable. Yet technological progress requires people willing to attempt things that others consider impractical.

Musk did not personally invent every technology associated with his companies. But he helped assemble the engineers, capital, factories, and organizations needed to make difficult technologies work at scale.

History provides useful parallels.

Thomas Edison was combative, fiercely competitive, and sometimes ruthless. During the battle over competing electrical systems, he backed animal electrocutions to demonstrate the supposed dangers of alternating current. Yet his work on practical electric lighting, sound recording, and industrial research helped transform modern life.

Henry Ford was a notorious antisemite who promoted conspiracy theories through his publications. Yet his application of mass-production techniques brought automobile ownership within reach of ordinary Americans. The price of a Model T fell from $850 in 1908 to $260 by 1925. Ford helped democratize personal mobility. Furthermore, his perfection of the moving assembly line revolutionized global manufacturing. By establishing a blueprint for unprecedented efficiency, Ford’s methods were quickly adopted beyond the automotive sector, driving massive productivity gains and transforming industrial production worldwide. Perhaps paradoxically, the assembly line helped the Allies defeat Hitler by turning America into the arsenal of democracy.

Steve Jobs was famously demanding and could be cruel to colleagues. His perfectionism made him difficult to work with. Yet he helped bring personal computers, smartphones, and other transformative technologies to mass markets.

None of these examples proves that unpleasantness causes innovation. Many disagreeable people accomplish nothing, and many important innovators are personally decent. But the historical pattern raises an uncomfortable possibility. Some characteristics that make innovators successful also make them difficult to get along with.

Psychological research lends support to that possibility. In a 1998 meta-analysis, psychologist Gregory Feist found that highly creative people tended to be more open to new experiences, less conventional, more independent, more self-confident, and more ambitious than their peers. They also showed higher levels of hostility and impulsivity. The research concerned scientific and artistic creativity rather than entrepreneurs specifically, but it suggests that creativity and social agreeableness do not always travel together.

Here lies the real trade-off.

We would prefer brilliant innovators who are modest, considerate, politically inoffensive, and easy to supervise. Some undoubtedly fit that description. But if the psychological traits associated with exceptional creativity sometimes accompany arrogance, impulsiveness, and hostility to convention, society cannot assume that it can select for the former while eliminating the latter.

A society that places a high premium on conformity, deference, and social approval may discourage some of the very people most willing to challenge established technologies and institutions. The price could be slower innovation, fewer experiments, and delayed benefits for everyone else.

That does not mean suspending ordinary standards of behavior. Musk should be held accountable for violations of the law, misleading claims, and genuine harms caused by his decisions. His companies should face competition and the same legal obligations as their rivals. 

But there is a difference between enforcing standards of conduct and expecting that innovators possess socially acceptable personalities. We should be especially reluctant to turn personal dislike or political disagreement into a reason to dismiss their achievements or obstruct legitimate enterprise.

That matters because innovation creates benefits that extend far beyond the innovator. Cheaper access to space helps researchers and entrepreneurs who will never meet Musk. Better batteries help consumers who will never own a Tesla. Satellite communications serve people whose lives may depend on reliable connections. Competitors imitate successful technologies and improve upon them. The resulting gains can continue accumulating for generations.

Of course, other entrepreneurs might eventually have developed many of these technologies. The question is how quickly. Bringing useful innovations to market years or decades earlier creates substantial value. Those gains should count when we evaluate the people responsible.

Gibney is entitled to criticize Musk’s character, conduct, and exercise of power. But the documentary’s emphasis on his failings risks obscuring the extraordinary advances he has helped bring about.

I would prefer a Musk who was more considerate, more restrained, and less inclined to insult everyone who disagrees with him. But I cannot assume that the same man, stripped of his unconventional temperament, would have pursued the same extraordinarily difficult ambitions with the same determination.

The real choice is therefore not between praising Musk and condemning him. We can do both. It is whether society remains willing to accommodate difficult, unconventional people whose talents can produce enormous benefits for everyone else.

This article first appeared in The Dispatch on 10/20/2026.

Gallup | LGBT

Global Acceptance of Gay and Lesbian People Is Increasing

“Global attitudes toward gay and lesbian people are more positive today than at many points over the past two decades, although the world remains largely divided. In 2025, a median of 40% of adults across 120 countries said their local area was a good place for gay and lesbian people to live, while 44% said it was not.”

From Gallup.

QNews | LGBT

Supreme Court of Nepal Rules in Favor of Marriage Equality

“On June 18 2026, the Supreme Court of Nepal issued a binding directive order to the government to ensure equal marriage rights for gender and sexual minorities.

The court dismissed a counter-writ petition opposing these rights filed by Yuvraj Paudel.

The Supreme Court has the final authority to interpret Nepal’s constitution and laws, so legally, the Government of Nepal is constitutionally bound to obey and implement rulings.

In practice, the Nepali governments have had a mixed record in making this happen, often delaying or ignoring directives.

However, this final judgment provides much-needed certainty for same-sex couples who have already registered their marriages.”

From QNews.

Blog Post | Trade

How Open Economies Lead to Open Minds

Trade undermines bigotry and rewards toleration.

Summary: Trade tends to reduce prejudice by fostering cooperation, competition, and repeated interaction across groups. Economic theory and empirical research show that economic freedom and globalization are consistently associated with lower levels of nationalism, ethnocentrism, and discrimination. By enabling mutually beneficial exchange and expanding social contact, markets help cultivate tolerance and weaken “us versus them” thinking.


In earlier essays, I argued that trade makes us richer, more trusting, more honest, and more fair. Yet over the past decade or so, we have witnessed a growing populist backlash against globalization and international trade. Many critics portray international trade as an example of “foreign intrusions on national sovereignty.” At first glance, the backlash might seem to suggest that trade with outsiders breeds resentment, cultural tension, and ultimately prejudice. In this essay, however, I argue that trade mitigates discrimination and prejudice, paving the way for greater tolerance.

In Capitalism and Freedom, the late Nobel Prize–winning economist Milton Friedman dedicated a chapter to the market’s relation to discrimination. Drawing on Nobel Prize–winning economist Gary Becker’s groundbreaking work, Friedman wrote, “The preserves of discrimination in any society are the areas that are most monopolistic in character, whereas discrimination against groups of particular color or religion is least in those areas where there is the greatest freedom of competition.” He continued:

The man who objects to buying from or working alongside a Negro, for example, thereby limits his range of choice. He will generally have to pay a higher price for what he buys or receive a lower return for his work. Or, put the other way, those of us who regard color of skin or religion as irrelevant can buy some things more cheaply as a result.

Survey data can shed light on the relationship between trade and attitudes toward others. A study of international survey data published by the Brookings Institution found that feelings of national superiority and chauvinism were positively associated with opposition to global trade across multiple countries. On the flip side, pro-trade attitudes and greater exposure to global markets are negatively associated with nationalism, ethnocentrism, and prejudice.

For example, negative attitudes among Americans toward outsourcing appear to be associated with an “us versus them” mentality. According to a study by political scientists Edward Mansfield and Diana Mutz, switching from the most isolationist to the least isolationist outlooks predicted a fivefold increase in support for outsourcing. Shifting from the least ethnocentric to the most ethnocentric attitudes predicted a 50 percent decrease in support for outsourcing. And changing from the least nationalistic to the most nationalistic views predicted a 25 percent decrease in support for outsourcing (see Figure 1).

Figure 1. Support for Outsourcing by Level of Nationalism

Source: Edward D. Mansfield and Diana C. Mutz, “US Versus Them: Mass Attitudes Toward Offshore Outsourcing,” World Politics 65, no. 4 (2013): 601. Perceived national superiority reduces support for outsourcing when the economic practice is explicitly labeled as “outsourcing.” This is the “Mentioned outsourcing” line. When the same economic practice is described without using that specific term, the same pattern does not occur. This is the “No mention of outsourcing” line.

The evidence compounds. Employing data from the General Social Surveys conducted from 1977 to 2010, Northwestern University’s James Lindgren found that racism, intolerance toward out-groups (e.g., homosexuals, atheists, and others), anti-capitalism, and pro-redistribution go hand-in-hand. Even after controlling for gender, logged income, education, age, and year of the survey, Lindgren showed that racism and intolerance are still strong predictors of socialist pro-redistribution and anti-capitalist attitudes. Lindgren’s analysis led him to conclude, “Those who support capitalism and freer markets and oppose greater income redistribution tend to be . . . less traditionally racist” and “less intolerant of unpopular groups.”

That tracks with the work of the Mercatus Center’s Virgil Henry Storr and Ginny Choi, who compared respondents from market societies to those in nonmarket societies using the World Values Survey. When asked who they would not like to have as neighbors, those in market societies were less prejudiced against those of a different race, language, or religion, as well as foreign workers, homosexuals, and cohabitating couples (see Figure 2). Trade, it seems, is next to good neighborliness.

Several studies by economists Niclas Berggren and Therese Nilsson investigated the relationship between tolerance, economic freedom, and globalization. The evidence they gathered suggests a causal relationship between the level of economic globalization and the willingness of parents to teach their children tolerance. Another analysis found that economic freedom plays a seemingly causal role in parents teaching their children tolerance and fostering tolerance toward homosexuals and people of different races (see Figure 3). Focusing solely on the United States, Berggren and Nilsson found a similar causality: Economic freedom increases tolerance toward homosexuals, atheists, and communists. Another study found that economic freedom increases tolerance toward homosexuals, particularly in societies that are high in trust.

Figure 2. Market Societies Are Less Prejudiced

Source: Virgil Henry Storr and Ginny Choi, Do Markets Corrupt Our Morals? (Palgrave Macmillan, 2019), p. 174.

Figure 3. Racial Tolerance and Economic Freedom

Source: Niclas Berggren and Therese Nilsson, “Economic Freedom as a Driver of Trust and Tolerance,” in Economic Freedom of the World: 2020 Annual Report, eds. James Gwartney et al. (Fraser Institute, 2020), p. 196.

And it’s not just parents teaching children tolerance. The media also plays a role in shaping our outlook. An interesting study by researchers at St. Olaf College, Stanford University, and George Mason University combed through a corpus of New York Times articles written over a 20-year period in search of moral language that Americans used in discussing other countries. They then measured the US market interaction with these countries by looking at bilateral trade flows and immigration statistics. Their results indicated that the more market interaction the United States had with a country through trade and immigration, the more news articles contained humanizing language toward that country. We tend to be cordial toward those we do business with.

Of course, it’s easy to say you’re tolerant in a survey or write nice things in an op-ed. It may even be socially desirable. We all want to look good. But does this translate into action? Several studies suggest that it does.

A clever set of experiments published in the European Economic Review showed that both local (monopsonist) and wholesale (competitive) buyers in the Bangladeshi rice market held prejudicial views of ethnic minorities. Prejudicial attitudes were the same across the board. Yet the wholesale buyers quoted the same price for both ethnic majority and minority farmers, whereas the local buyers did not. Why? The authors concluded, “This suggests that the taste-based discrimination that these buyers have against the ethnic minority group . . . can be eliminated if competition is strong enough.”

Those findings were supported by another set of experiments that demonstrated that market exchange decreases discrimination by increasing participants’ focus on their personal gains and reducing identification with their social in-group. Banking deregulation yielded similar results: As the financial sector was deregulated, competition intensified, leading to reduced discrimination against women and minorities.

Protectionist restrictions can exacerbate prejudicial attitudes. As the late economist Walter Williams explained, anti-competitive regulation “lowers the private cost of discriminating against the racially less-preferred person.” But when there is money to be made, trading only with groups who look or think like you doesn’t seem so important. And the more you trade with different groups, the more you realize that maybe, just maybe, they aren’t as bad as you thought.

But let’s go a step further. Researchers at the University of British Columbia and Bates College have also shown how trade can break down prejudice in practice. The researchers examined areas along the Silk Roads, a network of trade routes throughout Eurasia that has been used for over millennia. It turns out that areas within 50 kilometers of the Silk Roads today have higher economic activity compared to those that are 50–100 kilometers away. No real surprise there. But more importantly for our purposes, the former areas also have higher rates of intergroup marriage. It’s hard to find a better example of tolerance than asking someone of another ethnic group to become family and spend the rest of their lives with you.

You see this in 19th-century America as well. Railroad-driven market integration between 1850 and 1920 helped reshape American social horizons. A new study found that as counties gained better access to this intrastate trade, the likelihood of marrying someone outside the local community increased. That’s what’s called extra-community marriage. Other signs of tolerance and trust became apparent: Newspapers began to adopt language that reflected generalized trust. Parents began to give children nationally popular names rather than locally distinctive ones, implying a social circle that had extended beyond the local community. But one of the strongest findings was the increase in religious diversity: A 1 percent increase in market access raised religious diversity by 0.27 standard deviation, indicating a greater tolerance for religious identity and practice. Perhaps most striking, families who moved to these more market-integrated areas adapted quickly, especially those working in commerce-intensive industries such as agriculture, manufacturing, wholesale, retail, and transportation.

The available evidence suggests that repeated exchange softens suspicion toward outsiders. Sustained commercial contact makes unfamiliar people feel less distant and, consequently, less threatening. Trade provides a mechanism through which tolerance is learned and reinforced. As the 18th-century English theologian and scientist Joseph Priestly noted over 200 years ago,

By commerce we enlarge our acquaintance with the terraqueous globe and its inhabitants, which tends to greatly expand the mind, and to cure us of many hurtful prejudices. . . . No person can taste the sweets of commerce, which absolutely depends upon a free and undisturbed intercourse of different and remote nations, but must grow fond of peace, in which alone the advantages he enjoys can be had.